• Follow us

Economy

India Inc is growing disenchanted with Narendra Modi

IN MAY CHAMPAGNE corks popped as Mumbai’s bankers, investors and industrialists feted the re-election of Narendra Modi as India’s prime minister. His Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party’s defeats in regional elections last autumn raised the possibility of a return to power of the left-leaning Congress party, which most of India Inc views (with some justification) as anti-business, corrupt and fiscally feckless. Mr Modi’s landslide victory therefore set corporate pulses racing. The Mumbai stockmarket soared to a record high. So did expectations that he would follow first-term coups like a new bankruptcy code and a goods-and-services tax with fresh business-friendly measures. “Modi knows how to change the goalposts,” gushed one respected tycoon on election night. His fellow moguls nodded in agreement.

Two months later, the elation is gone. Despite an uptick in August, Mumbai’s Sensex stock index is about as close to October’s lows as it is to June’s highs. In July foreigners pulled more money out of Indian equities than they put in. India’s cautious business press has begun to criticise the government. So too, even more gingerly, have its cowed business leaders. “There is no demand and no private investment,” groused Rahul Bajaj, chairman of Bajaj Auto, a motorcycle-maker, at its annual meeting in late July. “So where will growth come from?” The remark, widely interpreted as a swipe at Mr Modi, encapsulates Indian business’s disenchantment with the man they once regarded as their champion.

Get our daily newsletter

Upgrade your inbox and get our Daily Dispatch and Editor's Picks.

Nirvana no more

The immediate cause of the mood swing was the budget, presented on July 5th by Nirmala Sitharaman, the newly appointed finance minister. Business folk tuned in to the two-hour presentation expecting less red tape, fewer tariffs, more incentives for investment and lower taxes. They got the opposite.

At an international bank, analysts’ feigned interest turned to mild bewilderment, then despair, as Ms Sitharaman recited the budget’s 143 provisions. The top marginal tax rate for high-earners would increase from 35.9%, already above the level in most emerging economies, to 42.7%, roughly as much as the average in the OECD club of mostly rich countries. The corporate-tax rate for big companies stayed at 35% (compared with a global average of 23%, and 21% in America). Or at least it appeared to: a new levy of 20% on share buy-backs, on top of existing charges, would bring the capital-gains rate above 40%, among the highest in the world. Add in a tax on dividends and a recently imposed charge on recipients and, all told, the government could skim off 60% of corporate profits. New tariffs would be slapped on products from cashews to newsprint to fibre-optic cables. One banker recounts listening to the speech from the shower, the last vestige of optimism washing down the drain.

As observers unpacked the budget’s convoluted text over the subsequent weeks, unintended consequences became apparent. To close loopholes, the bill extended taxes to the kinds of trust used by foreign portfolio investors, whom the government hopes to court. This turned them from heavy buyers of Indian equities to net sellers. Some high-earners wonder if it is time to decamp to more functional, business-friendlier Dubai or Singapore—especially after India’s parliament amended the Companies Act on July 30th to let the government jail executives at big firms that do not spend part of their post-tax profits on corporate social responsibility.

All this looks like an odd way to boost India’s flagging animal spirits—the deeper reason for corporate India’s malaise. Anomalies in the country’s GDP numbers, not all of which can be blamed on Mr Modi, have raised suspicions that India’s growth rate may have been significantly overstated. Indians are beginning to skimp on hair oil, toothpaste and other essentials, hitting retailers and consumer-goods firms. Collapsing car and tractor sales in the past couple of months are reverberating down the supply chain, from parts-makers to steel companies. Demand for building materials is so feeble that one industry bigwig says his workers mostly perform maintenance work. Exports are stagnant. Companies caught up in China’s trade row with America are relocating their supply chains to Bangladesh and Vietnam, not India.

The budget—and the statist signal it sends—is unlikely to encourage new spending by either domestic firms or foreign ones. Business investment has been sluggish since 2015, a year after Mr Modi first took office, a state of affairs for which the government is, again, not solely to blame. Lots of firms borrowed heavily to invest earlier in the decade, when India’s economy appeared to be on a roll. Its subsequent wobble exposed a Himalaya of bad loans, particularly at state-owned banks which dominate lending. More recently, liquidity and solvency crises hit shadow banks, which finance some businesses and many consumer purchases, including cars and motorbikes. Investments are the last thing on struggling bosses’ minds.

Announcements of new capital spending tracked by the independent Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE) fell from 10.3trn rupees ($207bn) in the first quarter of 2009 to 2.4trn rupees from January to March this year. Instead, companies have returned a growing share of profits to shareholders. Combined, the two trends do not exactly amount to a vote of confidence in India Inc’s prospects.

Powerful industries with lots of workers and lobbyists, such as vehicle manufacturers who want a cut in the 28% sales tax on their products, are seeking favour with the government. Everybody else has to cut costs, slash investments and cling on to cash, chief executives grumble. Both listed and unlisted firms’ return on equity, which began Mr Modi’s first term well below a peak in 2006-07, ended it lower still (see chart). Profits at 399 of India’s biggest public companies have declined by 3.7% a year on average on his watch, according to Refinitiv, a data provider. The CMIE calculates that asset utilisation has dropped from 50% in the 2000s to below 40%.

Tranquillity and mindfulness

Asked on July 8th about the post-budget stockmarket rout, Ms Sitharaman replied that she did not let this sort of thing “affect my calms”. If so, warned one financier at the time, “then the markets will fall until her calms are affected”.

Whether or not the subsequent falls rattled the minister herself, they appear to have jolted the government. Its initial response was to drag bosses in for confidential consultations, including at least one attended by Mr Modi himself. The officials’ conclusion, says a person close to the events, was that messaging was the problem, not the message. Ms Sitharaman was dispatched to pose for photos, listening to the concerns of bankers and captains of industry. This was a welcome change from the Modi government’s previous insularity. So was its promise, in response to panicked pleas from companies, not to lock up executives for stinting on social projects. The central bank’s 35-basis-point cut in interest rates on August 7th raised spirits. But neither removes the desert of sand that still silts up the wheels of Indian commerce.

Businesspeople who have spoken with Mr Modi say he is clever and focused. In private, they insist, he gets the need for a less overweening officialdom. They praise the bankruptcy code (though it was partially stymied by the courts) and excuse missteps, such as a disruptive withdrawal from circulation of certain banknotes. (They do not talk about his sometimes ugly Hindu nationalism.) Some speculate, longingly, that the business-bashing is part of a cunning strategy to distance himself from the wealthy in order, when the time comes, to reform India’s stifling labour laws.

Yet they also confide that the prime minister often asks not what the government can do for companies, but what they can do for the government. He is increasingly viewed not as broadly pro-market but selectively pro-business. His goodwill extends to companies whose goals align with his own: bankers who offer cheap loans to the poor, energy firms which furnish households with gas and electricity, corporations which improve sanitation in villages near their factories. Favoured firms are kept on life support with credit from state-controlled lenders, leaving less capital for everyone else.

Such complaints aren’t widely heard, not because they are rare but because they are not made in public. Sotto voce, denizens of India Inc say they fear retribution from the authorities. Criticism can provoke a call from an official that carries the implied threat of lost contracts or withdrawn permits, they say. After the suicide in July of the founder of a coffee chain who claimed to have been harassed by the tax authorities, the term “tax terrorism”, first coined in 2014, has gained new traction. Indian entrepreneurs share stories of protracted investigations that cripple businesses.

Most of these problems are endemic in India. Despite the liberalisation of the “Licence Raj” in the early 1990s the country has never quite let go of its deeply ingrained interventionism. But the prime minister, whose 13-year tenure as chief minister of the western state of Gujarat won him a reputation for sound economic management, was going to be different, members of the put-upon corporate class hoped. As he begins his sixth year as India’s prime minster, some of them are beginning to wonder if the state’s success owes more to go-getting Gujaratis than to their erstwhile leader. ■

Read More



Leave A Comment

More News

BBC News - Business

BBC World News business headlines 2019-09-13 12:56:02The latest international business headlines from BBC World News.

WeWork founder Adam Neumann's voting power curbed 2019-09-13 09:15:19The office space firm changes its structure after investor fears put its stock market debut in doubt.

Customers in the dark over pawnbroker closures 2019-09-13 08:15:29Albemarle & Bond and Herbert Brown stores have closed their doors, but a helpline is unanswered.

Pound climbs to highest level since July 2019-09-13 07:19:40Sterling rises as traders believe the risk of a no-deal Brexit is receding.

‘My boss lets me set my own salary’ 2019-09-13 04:13:58How picking your own pay has become the latest employment perk.

High-tech ways to keep employees happy 2019-09-12 19:26:04Companies offer gym deals and cycle schemes - but how do they know if these are what staff want?

How bottled water became a million dollar idea. 2019-09-12 19:21:44The BBC's Aaron Heslehurst explains how bottled water became a million dollar idea.

Sainsbury's pledges to halve plastic packaging by 2025 2019-09-12 19:06:43The supermarket is asking the public for ideas on how best to reduce its packaging.

YouTube advertises big brands alongside fake cancer cure 2019-09-12 19:02:39The video site's algorithm promotes medical misinformation in a number of languages, the BBC finds.

BA cancels 27 Sept flights ahead of next 2019-09-12 14:24:11British Airways has begun emailing thousands of passengers ahead of another day of strike action.

US gun laws must be stricter, say business 2019-09-12 12:15:20The leaders of 145 companies send a letter to Congress about "an urgent public health crisis".

Google to pay €1bn to end French tax 2019-09-12 12:04:39The settlement ends a four-year investigation into Google's tax affairs.

Reuters: Business News

Exclusive: WeWork considers dramatic valuation cut in IPO 2019-09-13 13:49:44WeWork owner The We Company may seek a valuation in its upcoming initial public offering of between $10 billion and $12 billion, a dramatic discount t

UPS to pay $8.4 million to resolve U.S. 2019-09-13 13:45:36United Parcel Service Inc has agreed to pay the United States $8.4 million to resolve allegations it overcharged federal agencies for package deliver

PG&E settles wildfire claims with insurers for $11 2019-09-13 13:44:38PG&E Corp said on Friday it has reached an $11 billion settlement to resolve most claims by insurance carriers related to 2017 and 2018 wildfires

Apple, Broadcom keep Wall Street gains in check 2019-09-13 13:29:44Losses in shares of U.S. technology majors Apple and Broadcom held the S&P 500 just under record levels on Friday, as traders balanced the latest

Crisis-hit Boeing readies huge effort to return 737 2019-09-13 13:05:50As Boeing Co sets its sights on winning approval to fly its 737 MAX within weeks, following a six-month safety ban, engineers around the world are ro

Factbox: What needs to happen before Boeing's 737 2019-09-13 13:04:58Boeing Co's best-selling jet, the 737 MAX, was grounded globally in March, days after the crash of an Ethiopian Airlines flight that followed a simi

Solid U.S. retail sales calm some worries about 2019-09-13 13:02:01U.S. retail sales increased more than expected in August, pointing to solid consumer spending that should continue to support a moderate pace of econo

IMF has a decision to make in Argentina: 2019-09-13 12:56:52The International Monetary Fund has a tough choice to make in Argentina: Unlock over $5 billion in funds under the country's loan deal as the governm

U.S. appeals court says Trump cannot dodge foreign 2019-09-13 12:54:32A U.S. federal appeals court on Friday revived a lawsuit alleging President Donald Trump violated the U.S. Constitution by profiting from foreign and

VW CEO shifts strategy from empire building to 2019-09-13 12:50:03Volkswagen has abandoned its decades-old obsession with empire building and no-expense-spared engineering to free up resources for the development an

Hong Kong exchange vows to press on with 2019-09-13 12:33:54Hong Kong's exchange refused to give up on its bid to take over the London Stock Exchange after the British bourse emphatically rejected its $39 bil

Indian's top trader body seeks ban on Amazon, 2019-09-13 11:35:03A leading Indian trader body asked the government on Friday to ban upcoming festive sales on Amazon's local unit and its rival Flipkart, saying their

Business News - UPI.com

Report: Air Force calls diversion of funds for 2019-09-13 15:56:53 The U.S. Air Force, in a report revealed Friday, said the planned $3.6 billion diversion of military funds for a border wall is a risk of national se

Italy joins Britain, Sweden to develop Tempest fighter 2019-09-13 15:46:36 BAE Systems and Italian defense contractor Leonardo agreed to work cooperatively on the next-generation Tempest fighter plane.

U.S. Navy tests unmanned underwater vehicles in Arctic 2019-09-13 13:53:29 An ordnance disposal unit successfully tested its mine countermeasures capabilities in the Arctic Ocean in Alaska, the U.S. Navy said.

Thailand agrees to buy amphibious landing ship from 2019-09-13 13:10:19 Thailand agreed to purchase an amphibious transport dock ship from a Chinese shipbuilder for $200 million, with construction expected to take about t

Navy's Truman Carrier Strike Group deploys without its 2019-09-13 12:13:59 With the aircraft carrier Harry S. Truman sidelined with electrical problems, its surface escorts nonetheless began deployment from their East Coast

Morocco approved for $986M buys of F-16 ammo, 2019-09-12 16:08:43 The State Department has approved potential foreign military sales to Morocco worth $986M for TOW Missiles and additional F-16 ammunition.

Saab presents first Brazilian Gripen E fighter for 2019-09-12 13:47:36 Saab delivered the first Brazilian Gripen E aircraft to start initial flight test programs in Sweden. The aircraft will move to Brazil next year for

Boeing awarded $45M contract for U.S. Navy, Australian 2019-09-12 13:10:34 The Boeing Company has been awarded more than $45 million for P-8A aircrew training upgrades for the U.S. Navy and government of Australia.

In rebuke to China, Taiwan calls for closer 2019-09-11 16:03:17 A report released on Wednesday by Taiwan's defense ministry calls for closer ties with the United States and other countries in a rebuke to China's

Britain demonstrates its new autonomous naval surface vessel 2019-09-11 15:48:58 Britain's next-generation autonomous surface vessel had its first public display at a London military trade show on Wednesday.

Poland approved by State Dept. for $6.5B buy 2019-09-11 13:51:06 A potential $6.5 billion deal that could bring up to 32 F-35A Lightning II fighter planes, engines and related equipment to Poland's military was ap

Marines complete 10-day attack simulation exercise 2019-09-11 13:46:52 The U.S. Marine Corps announced a successful naval exercise in the Philippine and East China seas and in Okinawa, Japan, on Wednesday, which included

Home Page

Realty sector welcomes stimulus for stalled projects, but 2019-09-14 09:58:37They rued that the government has not adequately addressed the issue of demand slowdown and lower sales

Infosys opens new R&D centre in Arizona, to 2019-09-14 08:31:10Arizona Technology and Innovation Centre has a special focus on autonomous technologies, Internet of Things (IoT), full-stack engineering, data scienc

Measures for real estate are good, but may 2019-09-14 08:17:32Besides this special window, interest rate on housing building advance is proposed to be lowered and linked to the 10-year G-sec yields

Export promotion scheme, shopping fests: FM's new measures 2019-09-14 08:01:50Make sense of all the announcements made by Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman for the exports sector

Rs 70,000 cr package announced for exports, realty 2019-09-14 07:47:15For exporters, a new scheme for reimbursement of taxes paid on exports will come into effect from January 2020 to replace existing dispensations

Aadhaar verification to be must for new dealers 2019-09-14 07:29:09Those who don't want Aadhaar authentication, physical verification will be carried out, which will be completed in three days, Sushil Kumar Modi said

Take CMs' views before changing FinCom's terms of 2019-09-14 04:43:43the Centre changed the terms of reference of the 15th Finance Commission and mandated the panel to suggest ways for allocation of non-lapsable funds f

Gurgaon Metro on the wrong track! Poor location 2019-09-14 04:16:14The Rapid Metro was constructed by IL&FS Infrastructure in two phases. Low ridership, high cost and poor location is believed to be responsible fo

Drones hit two Saudi Aramco oil facilities, fire 2019-09-14 02:30:25Online videos showed a massive blaze on the horizon, with the apparent sound of gunfire in the background

Best of BS Opinion: Price cuts as good 2019-09-13 22:14:00Here's a selection of Business Standard opinion pieces for the day

Focus on sustainability of agriculture, not loan waivers, 2019-09-13 17:48:55RBI panel says banks should partner agri-tech firms to provide quick loans to farmers

Finance panel won't accept Centre's GDP forecasts, says 2019-09-13 17:42:26The medium-term fiscal policy statement, tabled as part of the Union Budget 2019-20, forecasts nominal GDP for 2019-20 to grow 11 per cent year-on-yea


Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.