• Follow us

Economy

Why India's rich don't give their money away

Indian IT billionaire Azim Premji recently became India's top philanthropist, sealing his place among the world's top givers. But his generosity has put philanthropy in the spotlight in a country where charity does not appear to match wealth. The BBC's Aparna Alluri reports.

With his recent pledge of $7.5bn, Mr Premji's total philanthropic contribution now stands at some 1.45tn rupees ($21bn; £15.8bn). This puts him in the same league of givers - as philanthropists are called - as Bill and Melinda Gates, and Warren Buffet.

What perhaps distinguishes him even more is that, unlike them, he is not one of the world's five richest people - the Bloomberg Billionaires Index ranks him at 51.

But the philanthropic world was not surprised at his new status.

"This is not unusual for him because he's been the largest contributor in India and, even the continent, for some time," says Deval Sanghavi, co-founder of Dasra, a strategic philanthropy firm. It works with some of the biggest donors in India, directing their money to various causes and non-profits.

In their universe, Mr Premji is a magnanimous "outlier".

The 73-year-old software tycoon has been giving his wealth away for a long time. In 2013, he became the first Indian billionaire to sign the Giving Pledge, an initiative by Mr Gates and Mr Buffet that encourages wealthy individuals to pledge half their fortunes to philanthropy.

He was just 21 when he dropped out of Stanford University to join Wipro, a company his father started in 1945. (He went back and finished school in 2000). Under him, Wipro, a refinery for vegetable oils, grew into one of India's biggest and most successful IT services firms.

An intensely private man, Mr Premji rarely speaks in public or to the media. Yet, over the years, his unusually modest lifestyle and his generosity have earned him many admirers. Stories about how he still flies economy, or how he has, on occasion, hopped into a rickshaw, impress many in a country that values frugality, especially among the rich.

News of his pledge came in a dry press statement issued by the Azim Premji Foundation and included no personal statement. According to one newspaper, he even asked "what's all the fuss about" when he was told that the pledge was generating headlines and buzz on social media.

Mr Premji is not entirely alone in his generosity. IT billionaires Nandan and Rohini Nilekani have pledged 50% of their wealth to philanthropy; Biocon's Kiran Mazumdar-Shaw committed 75% of hers; and many other families fund hospitals, schools, community kitchens, the arts and scientific research. All of them, like Mr Premji, are pledging their personal wealth, largely earned in their own lifetimes.

The Tata Trusts, endowed by the personal wealth and profits of one of India's biggest and oldest conglomerates, has been India's biggest philanthropic outfit for decades. It is only now rivalled by Mr Premji's foundation, which funds education, healthcare and independent media among other things.

"Premji's grant for the nation matches only what Jamsetji Tata and Dorabji Tata have done from a historical perspective," Amit Chandra, managing director, Bain Capital, told the Economic Times newspaper. Mr Premji's contributions over the past decade, he added, stand out across more than a century of Indian philanthropy - the first Tata trust was set up in 1892.

Mr Premji accounted for 80% of the money given away by ultra-rich donors in India (anyone who has given more than $1.4m) in the 2018 financial year, according to a recent philanthropy report co-authored by Dasra and Bain.

Philanthropy is growing, says Mr Sanghavi, but it's not growing fast enough. Private philanthropy in India grew at a rate of 15% per year between 2014 and 2018.

The Dasra report sees this as "particularly problematic" since ultra-rich households have grown at a rate of 12% over the past five years and are expected to double in both volume and wealth by 2022.

Compared to the percentage of net worth given away in the US every year, the report estimates that India's rich could give $5bn to $8bn more each year.

What is stopping them?

"There is a great fear of the taxman," says Ingrid Srinath, director of the Centre for Social Impact and Philanthropy at Delhi's Ashoka University.

"They [the rich] don't want to end up on any radar or become the subject of more appeals for money."

She believes another reason could be that wealth in India is still only one generation old, and those who have it don't feel secure enough to give it away.

But Ms Srinath also cautions against wholly relying on the data as it is incomplete, making it "hard to say anything definitive about philanthropy in India".

There is no centralised directory tracking philanthropy in India. Tax laws are complex and there aren't many incentives for giving. So reports, such as the one by Dasra, rely on multiple sources, from the government to third-party trackers to individual declarations.

And many people give anonymously, which further complicates estimates of philanthropy.

"It's not considered cool to talk about how much you are giving," Ms Srinath says. Ashoka University, she adds, was partly funded by some 100 donors, each of whom gave more than $1.4m but refused to be acknowledged publicly.

But Anant Bhagwati, one of the authors of the Dasra report, says that no matter how weak the data collection, large pledges are unlikely to fall through the cracks.

"If you look at those who have the money, they are not giving it," he says.

Ms Srinath agrees: "The overwhelming sentiment is that we [Indians] could do better."

Charity vs philanthropy

Mr Bhagwati doesn't discount donors who fund individual universities or hospitals, but what Indian philanthropy needs, he says, is people who commit to solving a problem. And not just any problem - preferably, one of the daunting sustainable development goals or SDGs. These range from ending poverty and hunger to giving people access to clean energy.

Strategic philanthropy - which Dasra advocates - makes a distinction between charity and philanthropy. While the former might involve feeding the poor on a single day, the latter would require investing in non-profits that work to decrease or end hunger altogether.

By this measure, rich Indians might be charitable, but not enough of them are philanthropists.

Read more stories from India

More importantly, Mr Bhagwati says, philanthropy needs donors who will invest in the fight itself. By this he means pledges that don't specify how the money is to be spent.

So, for instance, a non-profit that works to improve sanitation could use donor funds to build toilets, hire more people or even buy a laptop or other equipment that might make them more efficient. But most donors, Mr Bhagwati says, will set conditions about how they want the money spent. In other words, they will insist on the toilets being built.

He calls this "restricted giving" and says it's hard to coax people to give any other way.

But some of this is changing. "Earlier you gave as much as you could and hoped something came of it," Ms Srinath says, adding that earlier, most people wanted to fund education.

"Education is to Indian philanthropy what cricket is to Indian sport," she says, laughing.

But now, she adds, Indian philanthropy is finally diversifying into areas beyond education - sanitation, mental health and scientific research.

The biggest challenge has been the gap between what Mr Sanghavi calls "action and intent". Some billionaires are just more willing to give their wealth away than others.

He says he has heard several Indian philanthropists, including the Nilekanis, speak of how they see themselves as "trustees" of their wealth, which, according to them, rightfully belongs to the larger community. That is, they believe they owe the world their wealth.

In a note explaining his decision to sign the Giving Pledge, Mr Premji said his mother was the "most significant influence" in his life and that he was also "deeply influenced by Gandhi's notion of holding one's wealth in trusteeship".

Ms Srinath says philanthropists could be influenced by many things, from parents to community to faith. But generosity as a trait, she adds, is inexorably linked to a way of seeing the world and your role in it.

"It certainly has nothing to do with how much money you have."

Read More



Leave A Comment

More News

BBC News - Business

'I will fight tooth and nail to make 2019-04-17 19:12:31Two women share their stories of juggling senior jobs and being home carers.

Will AI kill developing world growth? 2019-04-17 19:08:04Automation could wipe out many jobs in developing countries, says globalisation expert Ian Goldin.

JP Morgan: Is Wall Street's first female boss 2019-04-17 18:00:46JP Morgan promotes finance chief Marianne Lake, making her a possible successor to Jamie Dimon.

Ivanka Trump: I declined father's suggestion of World 2019-04-17 15:58:51She says her father suggested the role to her, but she told him she was happy in her work.

Climate change: Central banks warn of financial risks 2019-04-17 12:20:41The heads of two major central banks warn firms they may "fail to exist" if they ignore threats.

Jet Airways temporarily suspends all flights 2019-04-17 10:43:54The Indian airline suspends all of its domestic and international flights as it seeks further funding.

Netflix to trial showing top 10 lists to 2019-04-17 09:32:14Streaming company Netflix is to trial showing UK users its most-watched shows over a weekly period.

EU proposes tariffs on £15bn of US products 2019-04-17 08:04:42The EU makes it latest move in a long-running dispute with the US over aircraft subsidies.

Helium balloons blamed for UK train delays 2019-04-17 08:01:52Network Rail says helium balloons are causing delays by getting caught in overhead cables.

UK to introduce porn age-checks in July 2019-04-17 07:34:17Sites that fail to comply will face being blocked by internet service providers.

Juventus shares slump after Champions League defeat 2019-04-17 06:54:33Shares tumble after Juventus is knocked out of the Champions League by Dutch club Ajax Amsterdam.

House price growth at six-year low 2019-04-17 06:25:46House prices rise 0.6% in the year to February, the slowest rate since September 2012, official figures show.

Reuters: Business News

Carlos Ghosn to be indicted on additional charge New! 2019-04-19 04:55:36Tokyo prosecutors are likely to indict former Nissan Motor Co Ltd Chairman Carlos Ghosn on an additional charge of aggravated breach of trust as early

Foxconn says it remains committed to Wisconsin investment New! 2019-04-19 04:11:12Taiwan's Foxconn said on Friday it remains committed to its contract to build a display plant and tech research facilities in Wisconsin, days after t

Nissan slams output cut report as 'completely incorrect' New! 2019-04-19 03:23:49Nissan Motor Co Ltd said on Friday a report by the Nikkei that it would slash production this year was "completely incorrect" and that it had lodged

Despite headwind, Japan's Nomura says intent on going New! 2019-04-19 03:06:46Japan's Nomura Holdings has no plan to follow the lead of Wall Street rivals and seek a tie-up with a commercial lender, its chief executive told Reu

Qualcomm's joint venture with Chinese province to shut New! 2019-04-19 02:15:22A joint venture between U.S. smartphone chipmaker Qualcomm Inc and China's Guizhou province will shut down by the end of the month, The Information r

HNA denies embezzlement claims as it fights for New! 2019-04-18 23:47:57Embattled Chinese conglomerate HNA Group has denied accusations of embezzlement and financial irregularity made by a rival group of shareholders in Ho

Tesla's Elon Musk, SEC get another week to 2019-04-18 22:15:18Tesla Inc Chief Executive Elon Musk and the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission will get another week to settle a dispute over Musk's use of Twit

Exclusive: New York Fed cracks down on Puerto 2019-04-18 22:13:09U.S. sanctions on Venezuela have led the New York Federal Reserve to crack down on Puerto Rico's $50 billion offshore banking industry, according to

National Enquirer to be sold to owner of 2019-04-18 22:11:16American Media Inc (AMI) said on Thursday it was selling its National Enquirer tabloid to James Cohen, whose family owns a magazine distributor and us

Oil prices inch up on signs of tighter 2019-04-18 21:51:08Oil futures edged up on Thursday as a drop in crude exports from OPEC's de facto leader, Saudi Arabia, and a draw in U.S. drilling rigs and oil inven

Uber's self-driving unit valued at $7.25 billion in 2019-04-18 21:49:23Uber's autonomous vehicle unit has raised $1 billion from a consortium of investors including SoftBank Group Corp, giving the company a much-needed f

Exclusive: Venezuela skirts U.S. sanctions by funneling oil 2019-04-18 21:25:06President Nicolas Maduro is funneling cashflow from Venezuelan oil sales through Russian state energy giant Rosneft as he seeks to evade U.S. sanction

Business News - UPI.com

Raytheon awarded $12.1M for AIM-9X tactical missiles for 2019-04-16 13:42:22 Raytheon has been awarded a $12.1 million contract for AIM-9X Sidewinder missiles for the U.S. Navy, U.S. Army and 21 allies.

Boeing awarded $65M in foreign military sales for 2019-04-16 13:22:56 Boeing has been awarded a 10-year $65 million contract to provide small-diameter bombs to 12 foreign nations, as well as others that have been approv

USS Ross tracked by Russian fleet after entering 2019-04-16 12:18:34 The USS Ross, an Arleigh Burke-class guided-missile destroyer, has been deployed to the Black Sea, where it will conduct security operations, as well

State Department approves new deal with Taiwan for 2019-04-16 10:31:36 The U.S. State Department has approved a $500 million possible foreign military sale contract renewal for training of Taiwanese F-16 pilots and maint

F-35As sent to U.A.E. for first Middle East 2019-04-16 08:50:09 The U.S. Air Force has deployed the F-35A Lightning II to the Middle East for the first time, with the aircraft landing at Al Dhafra Air Base in Unit

HII awarded $727.4M contract for Virginia-class sub materials 2019-04-15 13:03:32 General Dynamics has awarded Huntington Ingalls Industries a $727.4 million contract for procurement of long-lead-time materials for U.S. Navy's Vir

Boeing awarded $21.6M for GBU-57 'bunker buster' bombs 2019-04-15 12:12:24 Boeing was awarded a $21.6 million contract for sustainment of U.S. Air Force's GBU-57 Massive Ordnance Penetrator, known as a "bunker buster" bo

Keel laid for future USS Richard M. McCool 2019-04-15 12:08:01 The keel was laid for the future USS Richard M. McCool, Jr., an amphibious transport dock ship, at a ceremony at Huntington Ingalls Industries shipya

Boeing awarded $14B for upgrades to B-1, B-52 2019-04-15 09:14:41 Boeing has been awarded a $14.2 billion contract to modify, modernize and test weapons systems on B-1 and B-52 bombers for the U.S. Air Force.

Saab awarded $18M to supply Australian Army with 2019-04-12 11:48:38 Saab was awarded an $18 million contract supply the Australia's Army with its latest version of the portable bazooka-type weapons system.

GAO: Cost for president's new 23-helicopter fleet drops 2019-04-12 10:53:10 The cost to replace the U.S. president's aging helicopter fleet is about $234 million less since that originally budgeted in 2014, GAO says.

U.S. Defense officials lay out plans for Space 2019-04-12 10:04:35 Top Defense Department officials have detailed plans to develop the Space Force, recognizing "status quo is not sufficient" to confront adversarie

Christian Science Monitor |

Be Kind, Please Rewind: Oregon boasts last Blockbuster 2019-03-18 18:14:04All corporate-owned Blockbusters shuttered after the business belly-upped in 2010. The success of the last store of its kind in Oregon has thrive

Once a darling, Big Tech is now a 2019-03-18 18:14:04The push for regulating America’s largest tech firms is about more than Facebook. It’s about a world coming to terms with how information

Sign of hope or worry? When the dollar 2019-03-18 18:14:04Do dollar stores, which now outnumber McDonald’s restaurants, provide hope for low-income areas hungry for retail? Or is their arrival a symptom

Growth in 'gender-smart' investing helps women in business, 2019-03-18 18:14:04“Gender-smart” investing support a broad spectrum of initiatives that ultimately support progress for women and girls. The trend is likely

Behind Huawei’s court battle: open markets vs. national 2019-03-18 18:14:04This legal battle signals the rising strategic importance of internet security. The dawn of so-called 5G networks is raising the stakes, as the U.S. a

China to pass new law barring demands for 2019-03-18 18:14:04China is expected to pass a foreign investment law that will bar government authorities from demanding that overseas companies share technology s

GM shutters car production at Ohio plant 2019-03-18 18:14:04After more than 50 years of churning out cars and trucks, a changing consumer market is forcing General Motors to end vehicle production at its Lordst

Caregiving crisis? Employers slow to catch up to 2019-03-18 18:14:04Balancing work and family is a familiar challenge. We were intrigued by a new workplace survey that emphasizes the role that employers, not just gover

A Trump-Obama trend: revival of ‘Made in the 2019-03-18 18:14:04A US economic sector that many had written off has been showing strong new life. Our reporter looks at the trend’s durability and at the debate

Walmart phasing out greeters, workers with disabilities fear 2019-03-18 18:14:04In an effort to compete with Amazon, Walmart has turned its storefront "greeters" into more physically demanding "customer hosts," a move that cam

Stocks surge following US decision to postpone China 2019-03-18 18:14:04The US-China tech tug-of-war threatens to upend global trade. That's why the Trump administration's postponement of tariffs on Chinese imports signa

Beyond Amazon debacle, wider doubts about tax breaks 2019-03-18 18:14:04When New York City saw its deal for a corporate HQ collapse, some leftist politics was involved. But the bigger message may be rising scrutiny of whet

Home Page

LS polls: Mulayam, Mayawati share stage after decades, New! 2019-04-19 04:35:00Ending decades-long rivalry, SP patriarch Mulayam Singh Yadav and Mayawati Friday shared dais at an election rally with the BSP President describing t

Mukesh Ambani's debt-fueled bet on rising middle class New! 2019-04-19 04:31:00Asia's richest man has ambitions to take on Amazon.com Inc. and Walmart Inc. in India, where the power of the middle class is growing along with dema

Priyanka Chaturvedi quits as Cong spokesperson, likely to New! 2019-04-19 03:36:00Chaturvedi also changed the introduction in her Twitter account, where she had earlier clearly mentioned the posts she held in the party

LS polls: Major parties again fail to field New! 2019-04-19 03:14:00'Very few women are asked (to stand for elections),' said Santosh Ahlawat, the only woman MP from Rajasthan, and a member of BJP

Jet Airways saga: 2 grounded airlines in a New! 2019-04-19 03:04:00India's aviation sector is an investment conundrum: it's the world's fastest-growing aviation market that has seen 54 consecutive months of double-

Non-life insurance premium up 13% at Rs 1.7 New! 2019-04-19 02:35:00The 34 non-life insurers had a gross premium of Rs 1.51 trillion in 2017-18

Will take Rahul to UK court: Lalit Modi New! 2019-04-19 01:34:00Taking a dig at the PM and in an indirect reference to fugitive businessmen Nirav Modi and Lalit Modi, Rahul Gandhi said, 'I wonder why all chor (thi

India's online retail mkt to cross $170 bn New! 2019-04-19 01:00:00The online retail can potentially increase to around 37 per cent of the total organised retail market during this period

Teenager's online petition to save father's job at New! 2019-04-19 00:14:00In the petition titled 'Saving future of 16,000 Jet Airways employees', she has sought instant financial help for the airline from the government.

Jet Airways issues gag order, asks employees not New! 2019-04-18 23:56:00Jet said talking with external stakeholders especially the media might impact the bidding process for airline's stake sale.

TikTok fans are searching for proxies after Google, New! 2019-04-18 23:45:00TikTok, which is very popular among children, is facing criticism for circulation of "pornographic content".

India rice rates dip as demand slows, Bangladesh New! 2019-04-18 23:15:00The country's rice exports for April-February dropped 9.4 percent from a year earlier to 10.57 million tonnes, as leading buyer Bangladesh trimmed it

Business

The subtle ways that discrimination works New! 2019-04-19 20:00:00In the workplace, it’s a still man’s world

Publicis buys Epsilon, a data-marketer, for $4.4bn New! 2019-04-19 20:00:00The deal hints at advertisers’ virtual designs

Chevron buys Anadarko for its shale assets New! 2019-04-19 20:00:00The $33bn megadeal signals consolidation in the fracking business

India’s bankruptcy code collides with reality New! 2019-04-19 20:00:00A much-ballyhooed insolvency regime faces court challenges

Saudi Aramco looks downstream, and East New! 2019-04-19 20:00:00The oil giant’s shift towards Asia and beyond crude should worry its Western rivals

Big carmakers are placing vast bets on electric 2019-04-16 20:00:00From GM and Geely to Mitsubishi and Mercedes, giants of the industry are making battery-powered plans

Apple and Qualcomm settle a feud over patents 2019-04-16 20:00:00The agreement ends perhaps the most epic intellectual-property battle ever between technology titans

Do spring profits foreshadow an earnings winter? 2019-04-12 20:00:00Probably not

Amazon’s empire rests on its low-key approach to 2019-04-12 20:00:00Unflashy but high-powered machine learning powers everything from its fulfilment centres to the cloud

Lobbying in Donald Trump’s Washington 2019-04-12 20:00:00Advancing corporate America’s interests is no easier under the CEO president

Germany’s Mittelstand are hardly prepared for Brexit 2019-04-12 20:00:00Preparing for a hypothetical Brexit is too costly

Facebook dominates Afghan e-commerce 2019-04-12 20:00:00Recent changes to the social network’s newsfeed has made life harder for online retailers


Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.