• Follow us


Agriculture 2.0: Is lab-grown meat real life or is it just delicious fantasy? | Digital Trends

This article is part of Troubleshooting Earth: a multi-part series that explores the bold, innovative, and potentially world-changing efforts to wield technology as a weapon against climate change.

is lab grown meat real life or it just delicious fantasy mosa 002Mosa Meat Burger

If you’re a foodie with your ear to the ground, you’ve almost certainly heard of the “farm to fork” movement, designed to promote the serving of fresh, locally sourced produce. But how about “lab to table”?

Sure, it’s less catchy, but it’s also what many believe to be the future: the mass production of lab-grown meat that requires the killing of zero animals before it lands on your grill. It’s not just something that appeals to animal lovers, either. Lab-grown meat could, its proponents suggest, help the environment, while also producing significantly less food waste in the process.

In the past decade, the dream of lab-grown meat has shifted from science fiction to science fact. In doing so, it has sparked the creation of dozens of companies, and support from some of the biggest names on the planet. But is it truly the way of the future? Digital Trends took an extended look.

A long-term dream

You can thank Winston Churchill. Well, kind of. Back in 1931, before he was British Prime Minister, the famous wartime leader took a turn at culinary prognostication. Within 50 years, he suggested, it would be possible to “escape the absurdity of growing a whole chicken in order to eat the breast or wing.” This could be achieved by growing individual parts separately “under a suitable medium.”

is lab grown meat real life or it just delicious fantasy cultured beef 4  1 is lab grown meat real life or it just delicious fantasy cultured beef 7 2  1

Churchill was right. While lab-grown chicken is still far from mainstream, the idea has gained significant momentum in the years since then. A little over a decade ago, in 2008, PETA offered a $1 million prize to the first company that could bring lab-grown chicken meat to market. The prize money coincided with dozens of laboratories around the world taking on the challenge of cultured meat.

“When I presented the first cultured hamburger, I wasn’t aware of anyone working on cultured meat.”

A few years later, in 2013, a Dutch pharmacologist and Professor of Vascular Physiology at the Netherlands’ Maastricht University, unveiled the world’s first lab-grown burger. Its game-changing “clean meat” was produced using animal cells, but without the requirement of, you know, killing an actual animal as the food source. For many people, this was the first time that they heard about lab-grown meat. Like the PETA announcement, it sparked a wave of interest from entrepreneurs and venture capitalists.

“When I presented the first cultured hamburger, I wasn’t aware of anyone working on cultured meat,” Post told Digital Trends. “Now, there are over 30 companies working on commercializing this technology. The big meat companies like Tyson, Cargill and Bell Food Group have invested, as well as famous investors like Sergey Brin, Bill Gates, and Richard Branson.”

Today, Post is chief scientific officer for Mosa Meat, one of the leading startups working in lab-grown meat. There’s also the San Francisco-based Memphis Meats, Israel’s Future Meat Technologies, and many others. All have their own twists on the concept, although the broad strokes remain the same.

“[Our process involves] obtaining a small number of animal cells from high-quality livestock animals,” David Kay, senior manager of communications and operations for Memphis Meats, told us. “We figure out which of those cells naturally contain the attributes we need — superior taste, texture, and the ability to efficiently self-renew — and we take those cells and re-create essential conditions that exist inside an animal’s body, but without the animal.”

Benefits of lab-grown meat

As mentioned, there are several reasons why the world might be ready for lab-grown meat. Animal treatment and waste are two prominent explanations. “People don’t eat slaughter meat because of how it is produced; they eat it in spite of how it is produced.” That’s according to Matt Ball, a spokesperson for the Good Food Institute, a company which provides support to startups producing lab-grown food.

According to the United Nations, livestock is estimated to contribute approximately 15 percent of global gas emissions.

There is also a surprising environmental impact brought about by large scale cattle farming. Farting cows may not seem like the biggest problem we face as a planet right now, but according to the United Nations, livestock is estimated to contribute approximately 15 percent of global gas emissions. Flatulent bovines aren’t the extent of it, either. Livestock production uses a large amount of water, while the toxins used in farming can run off into natural waterways, destroying habitats and wildlife in the process.

“If we can replace the majority of livestock meat production with cultured meat production, there would likely be enormous environmental benefits,” Post continued. “One of the most devastating impacts of livestock production is that it entails mass deforestation. For example, around 70 percent of the Amazon rainforest has already been cleared for grazing. This not only causes mass loss of biodiversity, but also significantly reduces the world’s carbon sinks. It is projected that cultured meat production will use 99 percent less land, which would potentially allow for vast areas to be reforested.”

is lab grown meat real life or it just delicious fantasy cultured beef 02

As a scientist, Post said that he believes lab-grown meat can help address the “immeasurable harm” being done by livestock production to the environment. “I feel it is my responsibility as a scientist to try to help,” he told us. “I am very excited about the prospect of cultured meat to do good for people and our planet.”

Problems that need to be solved

Things aren’t quite as clear cut as all of this might sound, of course. There are still significant challenges which must be solved before we’re chomping down on lab-grown meat. “I would say there is no single bottleneck, but rather hundreds of problems that need to be solved,” Post explained.

On the science front, he said that there remain challenges around maximizing the proliferative capacity of the cells used, and optimizing their differentiation into muscle and fat tissue. Then there’s the issue of scaling, which requires the designing of a bioreactor-based large scale production system for mammalian cells, among other challenges. This scaling must also be done at a reasonable cost, if lab-grown meat is ever going to be a viable choice for most consumers. Producing the first lab-grown burger in 2013 cost $325,000. Two years, later this cost had dropped down to just $11.

How do you sell large numbers of people on the idea of eating protein that’s grown in a laboratory?

More prosaically, there’s the “yuck” factor, perhaps more charitably known as educating consumers. Everyone can understand the appeal of organic food, with its associated imagery of free range cows gamboling across open plains. But how do you sell large numbers of people on the idea of eating protein that’s grown in a laboratory? Given the continued PR headaches of genetically modified food, this is one heck of a tall order. And that’s provided that the product is both as tasty and affordable as its more traditional meat counterpart.

“I am confident we can solve [these problems], but it takes time,” Post said.

Does it really help the environment?

Another recent, and extremely troubling development, was a piece of research published in the journal Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems. Carried out by scientists from the University of Oxford, it suggested that lab-grown meat actually has the potential to be worse for the environment than cattle farming.

“There are still a lot of uncertainties around what large-scale cultured meat production could look like, and we don’t have any data from real-life production systems yet,” John Lynch, a postdoctoral researcher whose work focuses on the climate impact of livestock production, told us. “We therefore need to consider the range in potential energy requirements and physical inputs that may be required for cultured meat production before we can make a clear comparison with conventional meat.”

is lab grown meat real life or it just delicious fantasy cows getty

Lynch continued that the way in which we currently compare the climate impacts of different activities, by looking at their “carbon dioxide equivalent emissions,” can overlook some of the important differences between different greenhouse gases. “In the more energy intensive cultured meat systems that have been speculated, we might essentially be replacing methane emissions from cattle with CO2 from energy generation,” Lynch said. “This would not necessarily be good for the climate.”

Lynch does not dismiss the potential benefits of lab-grown meat. However, research such as this makes it clear how, in many ways, we’re still at the start of this particular journey.

The way of the future

Lab-grown meat may still prove to be the future — but, for now, the emphasis needs to be kept firmly on the word “future.” Sure, we’re closer than we were in Winston Churchill’s day, but there remains a long way to go. Early estimates of when lab-grown meat products will be available to buy in your local supermarket were once measured in months. Today, even the most ardent supporters of this dream are more likely to talk in years or even decades.

At present, the most promising short-term alternative to meat are plant-based alternatives. We’re not talking about your grandfather’s Quorn vegetarian mince, either. Here in 2019, the most exciting plant-based meat substitutes are things like Impossible Food’s “bleeding” veggie burger: a burger which not only boasts the same level of bioavailable iron and high-quality protein as you’d find in conventional beef from cows, but also an impressively accurate (though still not perfect) meat-like taste and texture.

Elsewhere, the Israeli company Jet-Eat and Spanish startup Novameat are working toward 3D-printed steaks, created from vegetable-based formulations. And in Google’s cafeteria, the search giant has experimented with replacing the shrimp served to its tens of thousands of employees with a “shrimp” created using specially-engineered red algae designed to look and taste the same.

This isn’t to say that lab-growing meat isn’t on the way, though. Its proponents remain as enthusiastic as ever.

“I believe that sometime in my kid’s lifetime, plant-based and clean meat will be very close to 100 percent of the global meat market,” Matt Ball of the Good Food Institute told Digital Trends. “I don’t have an estimate as to which will have the larger share of the market — plant-based or cell-based — but they will both displace industrial animal agriculture because they are inherently more efficient, sustainable, and humane.”

So maybe enjoy that farm-grown beef steak while you still can, eh?

To check out the rest of Troubleshooting Earth, head over to the series homepage.

Editors' Recommendations Read More

Leave A Comment

More News

Latest ITProPortal news

AWS Ground Station ties your messy cloud network 2019-05-24 07:30:46Renting out satellites just got a whole lot cheaper, Amazon says.

Plume Q&A: TalkTalk partnership discussed 2019-05-24 07:00:58Fahri Diner, CEO and co-founder of Plume, talks to IT Pro Portal.

Cybersecurity workers don’t have the tools they need 2019-05-24 07:00:37Many employees have too many tools that just add to the confusion.

What is the IoT? Everything you need to 2019-05-24 06:57:22All the latest news, updates and analysis on the IoT.

CIOs and IT directors are missing out on 2019-05-24 06:30:32IT leaders are missing out on valuable insights from voice data collection and analysis.

Trump says Huawei could still be part of 2019-05-24 06:30:06A ray of hope for the Chinese tech giant.

Has the micro-mobility bubble burst? 2019-05-24 06:00:38An exploration of the current state of the micro-mobility market.

British firms still don't have cyber resiliency plans 2019-05-24 06:00:03An email attack is imminent and they know it.

Third-party risks to consider—and manage 2019-05-24 05:30:06Four tips to help security decision makers effectively address the risks posed by relationships with technology vendors.

Election fever. Preparing for the ‘day after’ 2019-05-24 05:00:17Attitudes to data privacy and protection need a fundamental overhaul.

A guide to VPN troubleshooting- Fix all your 2019-05-24 04:30:22VPN has become an essential tool to access the unrestricted world of the internet.

Ten signs your company doesn’t do continuous delivery 2019-05-24 04:00:03Most organizations have DevOps or CI/CD initiatives, yet still struggle with Continuous Delivery. Here are the 10 most common reasons enterprises get

TechRadar: Internet news

Nintendo at E3 2019: what we want to 2019-05-23 13:28:05Here's everything we hope to see from Nintendo's special Nintendo Direct livestream at E3 2019.

Only one in ten NHS Trusts are fully 2019-05-23 12:59:46New data from OpenText shows NHS Trusts are still struggling to digitize despite the UK government's new Long Term Plan.

Apple Watch sale: Walmart has the Apple Watch 2019-05-23 12:56:10The Apple Watch 3 is on sale at Walmart and down to its lowest price of $199.

Best dedicated server hosting providers of 2019 2019-05-23 12:35:23If you need the ultimate in performance for your hosting, check these providers out.

Best cloud hosting services in 2019 2019-05-23 12:02:56Add resources to your website whenever it needs them…

Xbox at E3 2019: what we want to 2019-05-23 11:52:46We've put together a list of everything we're hoping to see from Microsoft at E3 2019.

PS5: all the games, specs, news, and rumors 2019-05-23 11:50:56We've finally got concrete details on what the PlayStation 5 will be like, direct from Sony.

The best Memorial Day sales 2019: a guide 2019-05-23 11:18:48Your guide to the best Memorial Day sales and deals going on from top retailers like Amazon, Home Depot, and Walmart.

Best domain name registrars of 2019 2019-05-23 11:08:02Save money and hassle by using one of these top-notch domain registrars.

Apex Legends looks in trouble as revenue drops 2019-05-23 10:53:30The financial picture isn’t looking great – we discuss why, and what EA could do to rectify the situation.

Get this VPN deal and bag 12 free 2019-05-23 10:50:01A special anniversary deal from a big name in VPN - help out your friends and family with this PureVPN deal.

Don't miss these cheap Xbox Live Gold subscription 2019-05-23 10:45:48Get a great discount on these Xbox Live Gold subscription deals, plus some Apex Legends coins.

TechCrunch » Enterprise

Microsoft makes a push for service mesh interoperability 2019-05-21 10:45:13Services meshes. They are the hot new thing in the cloud native computing world. At Kubecon, the bi-annual festival of all things cloud native, Micros

FlareAgent, a platform that automates real estate transactions, 2019-05-21 10:32:55The real estate industry is experiencing a bit of a rejuvenation. After years resisting the influence of tech, the industry is now feeling the entranc

Praqma puts Atlassian’s Data Center products into containers 2019-05-21 06:00:48It’s KubeCon + CloudNativeCon this week and in the slew of announcements, one name stood out: Atlassian . The company is best known as the maker

IDC: Asia-Pacific spending on AI systems will reach 2019-05-21 02:34:22Spending on artificial intelligence systems in the Asia-Pacific region is expected to reach $5.5 billion this year, an almost 80% increase over 2018,

Robin picks up $20 million Series B to 2019-05-20 08:37:24Robin Powered, a startup looking to help offices run better, has today announced the close of a $20 million Series B funding. The round was led by Tol

Wagestream closes $51M Series A to plug the 2019-05-20 08:35:08Getting your work wages on a monthly (not weekly nor biweekly) basis has become a more widespread trend as the price of running payrolls has gone up,

Under the hood on Zoom’s IPO, with founder 2019-05-17 14:00:22Extra Crunch offers members the opportunity to tune into conference calls led and moderated by the TechCrunch writers you read every day. This week, T

HPE is buying Cray for $1.3 billion 2019-05-17 09:50:35HPE announced it was buying Cray for $1.3 billion, giving it access to the company’s high-performance computing portfolio, and perhaps a foothol

Health at Scale lands $16M Series A to 2019-05-17 09:00:53Health at Scale, a startup with founders who have both medical and engineering expertise, wants to bring machine learning to bear on healthcare treatm

Unveiling its latest cohort, Alchemist announces $4 million 2019-05-16 11:30:08The enterprise software and services-focused accelerator Alchemist has raised $4 million in fresh financing from investors BASF and the Qatar Developm

SugarCRM moves into marketing automation with Salesfusion acquisition 2019-05-16 10:06:35SugarCRM announced today that it has acquired Atlanta-based Salesfusion to help build out the marketing automation side of its business. The deal clos

OpenFin raises $17 million for its OS for 2019-05-16 09:01:51OpenFin, the company looking to provide the operating system for the financial services industry, has raised $17 million in funding through a Series C

Digital Trends

Apple iPhone Lightning Dock gets price knocked down 2019-05-23 19:54:00Apple acolytes are always eager to buy brand-name products, and the Lightning iPhone Dock is a solid option as a desktop charging station. Secure your

HP drops killer deals on laptops with up 2019-05-23 19:46:53HP is currently dropping prices on Spectre x360, Envy, Pavilion, and Omen laptops during its Memorial Day event. So if you're in dire need of a new l

From Chromebooks to MacBooks, here are the best 2019-05-23 19:11:28Whether you need a new laptop for school or work or you're just doing some post-holiday shopping, we have you covered: These are the best laptop deal

Senator’s loot crate bill has the video game 2019-05-23 17:58:36In a new interview, Republican Senator Josh Hawley speaks on talking with the ESA about the loot crate ban bill, whether or not he believes this will

The best HBO series (May 2019) 2019-05-23 17:53:17Whether you prefer the twisted world of True Detective or the lovable techies that have quickly come to define Silicon Valley, you'll love our picks

The best movies on HBO right now (May 2019-05-23 17:31:36From The Hangover to Dawn of the Dead and everything in between, we've compiled a list of the best movies currently available on HBO, whether you're

Leica and Lenny Kravitz team up again for 2019-05-23 17:16:59How's this for over the top: The Leica M Monochrome Drifter, designed by Lenny Kravitz, uses a vegan python skin wrap and matching strap along with t

Switching to the ‘Un-carrier?’ Here’s a breakdown of 2019-05-23 17:03:29T-Mobile offers a number of plans for you and your family, but how do you know which one is best for you and your situation? Here, we break down the s

At Collision 2019, technology finds its purpose: Doing 2019-05-23 17:02:08Collision is ostensibly a startup show, with nearly 1,100 startups, 26,000 attendees, and conference tracks for pitching venture capitalists called Gr

Samsung Space Monitor (SR75) review 2019-05-23 16:37:45High-concept monitors can sometimes over-complicate thing. Samsung's Space Monitor, however, tries to fix that problem by lifting the monitor off and

Digital Trends Live: Amazon wearable recognizes emotion, Boring 2019-05-23 16:11:32On this episode of DT Live, we discuss Amazon’s new wearable device that recognizes emotions, the Boring Company hitting the jackpot in Las Vega

Game of Thrones revisited: 7 storylines set in 2019-05-23 16:06:18If you paid close attention in the first season of Game of Thrones, you'll realize that many arcs that seemed odd in the final moments were seeded al

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.