• Follow us


What Will Be the Right Price to Cut Congestion in New York?

New Yorkers love to tout their exceptionalism. Late Sunday evening, the state legislature in Albany handed city residents another first-of-its-kind distinction: New York will be the first US city to impose a fee for driving in a busy part of town. The congestion pricing plan is an effort to fight traffic—and to raise billions for the region’s floundering mass transit system.

The plan would, by 2021, establish a fee for cars or trucks entering the most hectic part of Manhattan, below 60th Street. A few people are expected to get a break on the charge, with planned exemptions or credits for low-income area residents, those with disabilities, and those who need to visit medical services in the area. But for everyone else, it should get a lot more expensive to drive around Manhattan—probably around $11 per car and $25 per truck. (Those numbers come from a state-commissioned task force on congestion pricing, but the Metropolitan Transportation Authority’s Triborough Bridge and Tunnel Authority will set the prices in coming months.) The agency might choose to assess variable fees, making it, for example, more expensive to drive in the congestion zone during rush hour or on weekdays.

The money collected through the plan is slated to go straight to the city’s public transit system. Officials say they expect the plan to raise at least $15 billion in its first five years for capital improvement projects—which just might have pushed the plan over the finish line, politics-wise. “What precipitated this thing getting passed is the subway crisis,” says Bruce Schaller, a former New York City transportation official. “It doesn't have anything to do with traffic speeds in Manhattan.”

It turns out that those twin goals—fighting traffic and raising lots of money—could be at odds with each other, at least a little bit. “It’s a funny kind of tension,” says Michael Manville, an associate professor of urban planning at UCLA’s Luskin School of Public Affairs. “Policymakers have to balance them.”

The congestion pricing challenge is straight out of the Economics 101 textbook. Make it too expensive and inconvenient to drive in Manhattan, and traffic evaporates—but the city will raise little money to invest in its struggling transit network. Set a lower price, making it still inexpensive and convenient to drive, and the city will raise lots of money for subways—but not relieve much congestion. The result: a bunch of cranky voters who don’t understand why it’s suddenly pricier to drive on still-crowded roads.

“The devil is very much in the details,” Manville says. “The details aren’t necessarily hard, but getting them right really does require understanding that if you want to reduce congestion, that should be your first goal, and the revenue comes after that. If you set out just to raise money, you do that—but you may not reduce congestion.”

To understand what’s at stake here, Manville likes to use an analogy: parking meters. When cities first started installing parking meters, officials saw them as a parking management tool. If transportation wonks found a pricing sweet spot, the thinking went, they could guarantee that anyone who desperately needed to park would always be able to find a spot, albeit for a hefty fee. Over time, though, more cities began to see parking meters as machines that could make them money. Parking still cost a fee, but not enough to disincentivize driving altogether. In other words: Meters are annoying but not overly burdensome for the average driver. And cities found themselves squeezed for parking once again.

Fortunately for New York, a bunch of other cities have used congestion pricing for years to reduce traffic and raise money, with mixed success. There is plenty to learn.

London, for example, rolled out a pricing scheme in its busiest downtown area in 2003, charging $8 to enter the 8-square-mile zone during weekdays. At first, it worked: Traffic delays fell by 30 percent, and the city estimates it has reduced vehicular emissions from the zone by 12 percent. But traffic has climbed back since the early 2000s, even as the charge has reached $16. Now it’s even slower going in the area than when the scheme kicked in 16 years ago. And that’s partly because the congestion plan’s writers couldn’t anticipate what was ahead: the explosion of on-demand delivery and for-hire vehicle platforms like Uber and Lyft, which are, along with taxis, exempt from the congestion charge. The London experience points to a hazard of congestion pricing: being too generous when deciding who can escape the tolls.

(A new NYC law already requires taxis to charge an extra $2.50 congestion fee, and Uber and Lyft drivers $2.75, while driving below 96th Street in Manhattan.)

Singapore, meanwhile, has had its own Electronic Road Pricing System since late last century and has used it to tamp down traffic, at least compared with similar big cities. The city reviews what drivers have to pay to use certain highways quarterly (from 40 cents to about $5) and adjusts the prices to account for changes that might shift traffic flows, like major new offices or housing developments. Despite that flexibility, though, average daily traffic volume in the island nation climbed by 22 percent from 2004 to 2014. But average expressway speeds went up in that period, and public transit ridership did, too. (Singapore also makes it extremely expensive to own a personal car—that also helps with traffic.)

So New York City has plenty of questions ahead, and plenty of work to do. And no one in the city should expect this congestion plan to save them from traffic forever. “This underscores that just doing congestion pricing is not enough to combat congestion or to get the system to work the way we want it to,” Schaller says. The really fun part is yet to come.

More Great WIRED StoriesA clever strategy for treating cancer, thanks to DarwinHow Zello became a lifeline for VenezuelansThe engine propelling the fastest woman on four wheelsThe best (and worst) mattresses in a box you can buyIt's a short hop from Fortnite to a new AI best friend👀 Looking for the latest gadgets? Check out our latest buying guides and best deals all year round📩 Want more? Sign up for our daily newsletter and never miss our latest and greatest storiesRead More

Leave A Comment

More News

All Motor Trend Stories RSS

10 Things to Know About Peugeot Coming to 2019-04-18 08:00:07Peugeot has accelerated its plans to launch its brand on North American shores, from its original, tentative 2026 timeframe to a more recent announcem

Hyundai Says Upcoming Sonata N Line Will Make 2019-04-17 19:21:32After Hyundai revealed the redesigned 2020 Sonata, it received both praise and criticism for the car’s bold styling. But unlike with its predece

7 Things to Know About the 2020 Toyota 2019-04-17 18:50:04Exactly 19 years after the first-generation Highlander was revealed at the 2000 New York auto show, Toyota took the wraps off the latest version of it

Daimler on Verge of Decision About Smart Brand’s 2019-04-17 18:23:12Daimler will make a decision soon on whether to stop selling the Smart brand in the U.S. “We’re deciding how to proceed with Smart in the

A Mazda6 Diesel Might Finally Make it to 2019-04-17 17:10:59At the 2019 New York auto show, Mazda finally made the availability of a diesel engine on the CX-5 official. The engine is a 2.2-liter twin-turbo I-4

Toyota Waits on Electric Cars as Volkswagen Forges 2019-04-17 16:30:12A $255 billion debate is raging among the world’s biggest automakers. Some think electric cars made by companies besides Tesla Inc. stand the ch

2020 Alfa Romeo Giulia and Stelvio NRING Edition 2019-04-17 16:00:39Alfa’s raison d’être, its unique selling proposition in a market crowded with brands currently enjoying stellar quality and reliabil

2020 Kia Stinger GTS Offers a More Drift-Happy 2019-04-17 16:00:23We weren’t expecting a “special edition” of the Kia Stinger so soon, but here comes the 2020 Stinger GTS, resplendent in orange pain

GM Says Ram’s Impressive Q1 Truck Sales Deserve 2019-04-17 15:20:04Earlier this month, we reported that for the first time in recent memory there had been a shakeup in full-size truck sales. The Ford F-series was

Mercedes-Benz EQC Edition 1886 Celebrates Brand’s Past and 2019-04-17 15:00:50In case you were concerned the forthcoming Mercedes-Benz EQC won’t be special enough to impress your GLE-driving neighbors, its maker just

2020 Toyota Highlander First Look: You’re a Highlander? 2019-04-17 00:01:58Let’s play a guessing game. Is this a new Subaru? Maybe a zippy Mazda? Ford Explorer? Wrong, wrong, and wrong. This fresh new face is the 2020 T

2020 Lincoln Corsair First Look: MKC Replacement Looks 2019-04-17 00:01:31We were anxious to see the 2020 Lincoln Corsair compact crossover for a couple reasons. Would it continue the strong design streak set by the Navigato


Why the Audi E-tron’s Range Came Up Short 2019-04-08 19:27:18The new electric SUV is yet another with a dispiriting EPA range rating.

Tesla’s Disappointing Numbers and More Car News This 2019-04-07 09:00:00Tesla's deliveries fell 31 percent in the first quarter compared with the fourth quarter of 2018. New York moves toward congestion pricing. And truck

Tesla Is Better at Making Cars. Delivering Them? 2019-04-04 17:38:00The always-exciting electric carmaker suffers its biggest drop in deliveries yet in the first quarter.

Audi's New Electric-Car Factory Goes Green 2019-04-04 08:00:00Electric vehicles consume more energy than gasoline-powered rides during manufacturing. Audi’s new E-tron plant tries to change that.

What Will Be the Right Price to Cut 2019-04-02 07:00:00New York will become the first US city to impose fees on driving in busy parts of town to raise money for its ailing subway system. But setting the ri

UPS Drones Are Now Moving Blood Samples Over 2019-04-01 07:00:00The FAA's first sanctioned, revenue-generating drone delivery service involves speeding up the movement of blood and tissue samples.

Inside a Ferrari Hypercar, Lyft’s IPO, and More 2019-03-31 09:00:00Plus, we ride the Jeep Gladiator and ponder the future of electric vehicles, courtesy of battery-swapping rickshaws.

Futures Aren’t Just for Juice. They’re for Truck 2019-03-31 07:00:00Many futures are for physical products, while others border on metaphysical. You can buy and sell on snowfall, box office returns, energy prices&mdash

The Jeep Gladiator Pickup Is an Off-Roading Tough 2019-03-30 00:01:00The $33,545 Gladiator is made for the toughest off-road conditions you can find—with a few creature comforts thrown in.

Lyft’s IPO Heralds a Wave of Gig-Economy Offerings 2019-03-29 18:21:00Lyft got a jump on rival Uber with its IPO. Investors liked the offering despite the ride-hailing company's growing losses.

India Goes Electric With Battery-Swapping Rickshaws 2019-03-29 08:00:00Because even an electric autorickshaw can be out of reach for many, SUN Mobility is trying a different tack to clean up India's air.

The Complex Quest to Write a Robocar Driving 2019-03-28 14:39:24Self-driving cars are patrolling our roads, and it's about time someone made a proper engineering standard that they can be held to.

Automotive news - from

Toyota plans first hybrid car made in Brazil 2019-04-18 12:05:00Toyota Motor said it would build a hybrid version of the redesigned Corolla sedan in Brazil that will run on electricity, ethanol and petrol, claiming

ZF and Foton open second transmission JV plant 2019-04-18 11:51:00Following the ZF establishment of two joint ventures with Chinese commercial vehicle manufacturer Foton in 2016, to produce commercial vehicle transmi

EV car-share schemes 'could help OEMs avoid EU 2019-04-18 08:55:00New EV car-sharing schemes could offer carmakers a path to avoiding EU fines that will be levied on companies that fail to achieve tighter average CO2

Jinkang Seres (SF Motors) launches first SUV in 2019-04-18 08:18:00Jinkang Seres, a subsidiary of Chinese automaker Sokon Group also known as SF Motors, unveiled a new battery-powered SUV at a company event held this

just-auto takes an Easter break 2019-04-18 08:12:00Easter is coming this weekend, which means Friday (19 April) and Monday (22 April) are public holidays for us, here in the UK.

Indonesia sales continue to fall in March 2019-04-18 08:06:00New vehicle sales in Indonesia continued to fall in March 2019, by over 11% to 90,189 units from 101,674 units a year earlier, according to wholesale

Uber attracting investors to self-driving unit - report 2019-04-18 07:21:00Ride-hail giant Uber Technologies is reported to be nearing a deal with a group of investors prepared to invest in its self-driving car unit.

SKF opens new tapered roller bearing factory in 2019-04-18 07:20:00SKF has inaugurated its tapered roller bearing factory in Changshan, China.

SEAT spent EUR7.137bn on purchases in 2018 2019-04-18 07:19:00In a record year for Volkswagen Group Spanish unit SEAT, the purchasing operation spent EUR7.137bn (US$8.061bn) in 2018, up 5.6% year on year.

Lear completes acquisition of automotive software supplier Xevo 2019-04-18 07:14:00Lear Corporation has announced it has completed its previously announced acquisition of Seattle-based Xevo, a leading automotive software supplier tha

Hella expands partner network for lighting and electronics 2019-04-18 06:53:00Hella has signed further cooperation agreements at Auto Shanghai, China's most important motor show.

Dana says acquisitions expand support for OEMs in 2019-04-18 06:47:00Dana has announced that the company had added five facilities in China since the start of the year. The increase is the result of Dana's recent

High Gear Media Network Feed

Ford Mustang is the best-selling sport coupe globally, New! 2019-04-19 13:00:00Buyers have plenty of options to choose from, but when it comes to sport coupes, the Ford Mustang is king. In a Wednesday release, Ford said the Musta

Ford Bronco Scout name trademarked: Is it the New! 2019-04-19 12:47:00The Ford Bronco is set to return in 2020, and it will get a smaller sibling known so far as the "baby Bronco." Now, thanks to a new trademark filing

2019 New York International Auto Show in pictures: New! 2019-04-19 11:50:00The 2019 New York auto show will open to the public Friday with a clear message from automakers: luxury for buyers comes first. It's no coincidence t

Bugatti Divo busy with hot-weather testing New! 2019-04-19 11:30:00Readying any new car for production is no simple process. Preparing to launch a new Bugatti only heightens the work. Bugatti is currently putting the

2020 BMW M3, Qiantu K50, Rivian future plans: New! 2019-04-19 11:00:00BMW introduced a redesigned 3-Series last year. That means a new M3 should be just around the corner. Our latest spy shots show a tester for the upcom

US EV startup Rivian plans 6 models by New! 2019-04-19 10:00:00Rivian presented concepts for an electric pickup truck and related SUV last November at the 2018 Los Angeles Auto Show, but the EV startup plans to fo

2020 Aston Martin DBX spy shots and video New! 2019-04-19 09:00:00Aston Martin's DBX SUV is on track for a debut in late 2019 and as part of the development a prototype has taken to Germany's Nürburgring for s

Qiantu K50 electric sports car starts US production New! 2019-04-19 08:00:00A new Chinese EV brand by the name of Qiantu is using a sleek, carbon fiber-bodied sports car to spearhead its launch in the United States, which kick

Toyota, SoftBank buy $1B stake in Uber's self-driving New! 2019-04-19 07:00:00Ahead of Uber's historic IPO in the coming weeks, the ride-hail giant's self-driving car division received a $1 billion injection from Toyota, inves

Daimler reportedly to end ties with Renault Nissan, New! 2019-04-19 06:00:00Daimler will seek to make major cost cuts and end ties with the Renault Nissan Mitsubishi Alliance, Manager Magazin reported on Thursday. According to

2020 BMW M3 spy shots and video New! 2019-04-19 01:45:00BMW’s benchmark sport sedan, the M3, will soon come in for a redesign. A prototype for the next-generation model been spotted again, revealing a

New Lincoln Zephyr to replace MKZ? 2019-04-18 16:00:00Ford's decision to kill off all passenger cars save for the Mustang has left Lincoln's two sedans in limbo. However, a new trademark filing suggests

The Truth About Cars

Former Top Nissan Exec Arrives at Hyundai, Asked 2019-04-18 16:35:32José Muñoz, who resigned as Nissan’s chief performance officer in January, is now on the Hyundai payroll. Muñoz j

2020 Subaru Outback Picks Up New Platform, Deep-sixes 2019-04-18 15:27:21For 2020, Subaru’s revered Outback wagon undergoes a host of changes while remaining unmistakably an Outback. And, as New York is hardly the fir

Hyundai’s 2020 Sonata: Optimized Engines, and an N 2019-04-18 13:48:24Staying true to its tradition of extremely bold styling revamps, Hyundai’s 2020 Sonata looks like something penned by a team of French and

Rare Rides: A Very Rare De Tomaso Guarà 2019-04-18 12:55:52The Rare Rides series has broached the subject of De Tomaso a few times before. The luxurious Longchamp coupe was accompanied by the Qvale-branded Man

Tireside Chat: Talking Design With Nissan 2019-04-18 12:27:22Designing cars is a mix of art and science – and it’s about more than just looks. Especially when the brand you work for has a lot on its

Volkswagen of America Boss Envisions Getting People Out 2019-04-18 11:52:53A Volkswagen concept that’s not really a concept appeared in New York City this week, aimed at gauging the American public’s level of inte

Nissan GT-R 50th Anniversary Edition Debuts in New 2019-04-18 11:05:19Generally, when most folks turn 50, they throw themselves a party and reflect on their first five decades while musing about aging gracefully. The Nis

Gird Your Loins, People – Ford Promises an 2019-04-18 10:06:48“Ford’s future is not about giving up the car,” company CEO Jim Hackett said in November 2017, not long before taking an axe to all

Mazda CX-5 Diesel: Giving Yourself the Skyactiv-D 2019-04-18 09:00:11Mazda has certainly bent over backwards to get its new diesel to the U.S. market. Originally slated to premiere inside the 2017 CX-5, Mazda&rsquo

Ace of Base: 2019 Ford Flex SE 2019-04-18 08:00:57Yep, they still sell this thing. Betcha forgot all about it. Or perhaps not. The “styled with a t-square” profile of the Flex has always a

2020 Mercedes-Benz GLS – Unabashedly Big and Not 2019-04-17 15:12:29It’s getting increasingly difficult to decide what constitutes a luxury vehicle these days. Premium manufacturers seem preoccupied with technolo

Freedom of Choice: Kia’s Stinger GTS Is Whatever 2019-04-17 14:31:17It’s strange how, after an automaker goes to the trouble of building a car aimed at the perpetually cranky enthusiast crowd, you can sometimes f

Automotive News Breaking

Audi joins forces with Marvel Studios' 'Avengers: Endgame' New! 2019-04-19 12:50:31Audi's hopes the Marvel collaboration will boost audience engagement and socialize the Audi e-tron crossover.

BMW adds 185,000 units to recall over engine New! 2019-04-19 12:13:53BMW said it monitored reports from the field and found "several field incidents" involving 2006 3-series vehicles, so the company added them to a No

Automakers look to Beijing to revive China's slumping New! 2019-04-19 11:41:01VW and Nissan are among the automakers increasingly counting on Chinese government tax cuts to stimulate demand and help boost the world's biggest au

Return of the bench seat? Concept EVs show New! 2019-04-19 11:34:24Infiniti's head of design, Canadian Karim Habib, says the center of the rear seat in EVs “can become just as valuable” as the s

FCA recalls 320,000 Dodge Darts that could roll New! 2019-04-19 09:32:08The callback, covering 2013-2016 models with automatic transmissions, addresses a defect that could prevent drivers from shifting into park.

German startup plans to build solar car at New! 2019-04-19 07:52:28German startup Sono is teaming up with National Electric Vehicle Sweden to build the first series production solar -powered electric car at Saab's fo

Brembo investors tighten grip on company with loyalty New! 2019-04-19 07:41:47Brembo shareholders approved a loyalty share program that allows the family that owns the Italian premium brake maker to retain control as the company

Nissan offers $112,000 to Notre Dame restoration New! 2019-04-19 07:10:49Nissan’s contribution is “in recognition of and appreciation for Nissan Europe and Renault employees as well as the people of France,&rdqu

Toyota, Denso, SoftBank invest $1B in Uber's AV New! 2019-04-19 06:35:23Uber's autonomous vehicle unit raised $1 billion from Toyota, Denso and SoftBank, giving Uber a funding boost for its self-driving ambitions on the e

Ghosn to be indicted on new charges, report New! 2019-04-19 06:04:09Carlos Ghosn will be indicted on a fresh round of charges as Japanese prosecutors pursue their case against the former Nissan chairman, broadcaster NH

Hyundai hires former Nissan exec Munoz for global, 2019-04-18 12:55:00Jose Munoz, the 20-year veteran of Toyota and Nissan, inherits a revitalized Hyundai vehicle lineup in the U.S. and comes with a reputation for pushin

Lear closes on $320 million acquisition of software 2019-04-18 12:16:13Xevo brings Lear the technology that connects drivers with cars and mobile apps through the cloud.

autoevolution news

Watch a 2019 BMW X5 Kidney Grille Glide 2019-04-18 11:45:36The latest results from the crash tests conducted by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) are in, and they include the rating for the 201

Fast Hobbs Takes On Furious Shaw in Action 2019-04-18 10:59:37Countless hand-to-hand fight scenes, a flamethrower, a fighter jet sitting on a lawn, a haka dance, and a bunch of cars chained together being dragge

Toyota Pushes Into European Compact Van Segment With 2019-04-18 10:55:39Toyota isn’t big on commercial vehicles in Europe save for the Hilux. But even in the mid-size pickup segment, the Ford Ranger reigns supreme in

2020 Jeep Gladiator Coming to Europe to Tease 2019-04-18 09:57:39There’s still about a year left until Jeep’s most recent nameplate, the Gladiator, reaches the shores of Europe, but that won’t stop

Volkswagen Tarok Small Pickup Truck Could Cost Approximately 2019-04-18 09:52:20Revealed in November 2018 in Brazil, the Tarok stopped by the New York Auto Show for Volkswagen “to gauge market reaction for a truly versatile

3 Passengers Open Emergency Exit, Climb on Boeing 2019-04-18 09:08:14Two Boeing 737 Max 8 planes were involved in deadly crashes in the last 5 months. Even if they hadn’t, looking out the window and seeing flames

Kia HabaNiro Brings Nothing But a Hot Name 2019-04-18 09:00:09Last week, Kia teased by means of a leaked image what seemed to be a very exciting concept wearing a weird name: HabaNiro. As the New York Internation

Texas Cops Issue Coloring Citation to Driver Parked 2019-04-18 08:45:28Sometimes, the best way to get somebody to pay attention to whatever you have to say is through humor, as officers from the Southlake Police Departmen

Lincoln MKZ Could Be Replaced With All-New Zephyr 2019-04-18 08:30:20Fresh from revealing the Corsair in New York as the replacement for the MKC, the Lincoln Motor Company could replace the MKZ with the Zephyr in 2021.

Bystander Jumps Into Stolen Pontiac, Brings it Back 2019-04-18 08:21:56A man from Kansas City, Missouri, proud to call himself the owner of a Pontiac, came very close to losing it for good when a thief jumped inside and t

Blue Origin to Test Rocket Engines at Former 2019-04-18 08:07:23Blue Origin’s upcoming BE-3U and BE-4 rocket engines will be tested by Jeff Bezos’ company at NASA’s Marshall Space Flight Center in

Detroit Tow Truck Hits 7 Parked Cars, Driver 2019-04-18 08:06:42A Detroit tow truck caused mayhem outside a local bar, hitting no less than 7 parked cars. The driver tried to leave the scene of the accident when an

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.