• Follow us

Social Media

Liberty’s challenge to UK state surveillance powers reveals shocking failures – TechCrunch

A legal challenge to the UK’s controversial mass surveillance regime has revealed shocking failures by the main state intelligence agency, which has broad powers to hack computers and phones and intercept digital communications, in handling people’s information.

The challenge, by rights group Liberty, led last month to an initial finding that MI5 had systematically breached safeguards in the UK’s Investigatory Powers Act (IPA) — breaches the Home Secretary, Sajid Javid, euphemistically couched as “compliance risks” in a carefully worded written statement that was quietly released to parliament.

Today Liberty has put more meat on the bones of the finding of serious legal breaches in how MI5 handles personal data, culled from newly released (but redacted) documents that it says describe the “undoubtedly unlawful” conduct of the UK’s main security service which has been retaining innocent people’s data for years.

The series of 10 documents and letters from MI5 and the Investigatory Powers Commissioner’s Office (IPCO), the body charged with overseeing the intelligence agencies’ use of surveillance powers, show that the spy agency has failed to meet its legal duties for as long as the IPA has been law, according to Liberty.

The controversial surveillance legislation passed into UK law in November 2016 — enshrining a system of mass surveillance of digital communications which includes a provision that logs of all Internet users’ browsing activity be retained for a full year, accessible to a wide range of government agencies (not just law enforcement and/or spy agencies).

The law also allows the intelligence agencies to maintain large databases of personal information on UK citizens, even if they are not under suspicion of any crime. And sanctions state hacking of devices, networks and services, including bulk hacking on foreign soil. It also gives U.K. authorities the power to require a company to remove encryption, or limit the rollout of end-to-end encryption on a future service.

The IPA has faced a series of legal challenges since making it onto the statute books, and the government has been forced to amend certain aspects of it on court order — including beefing up restrictions on access to web activity data. Other challenges to the controversial surveillance regime, including Liberty’s, remain ongoing.

The newly released court documents include damning comments on MI5’s handling of data by the IPCO — which writes that: “Without seeking to be emotive, I consider that MI5’s use of warranted data… is currently, in effect, in ‘special measures’ and the historical lack of compliance… is of such gravity that IPCO will need to be satisfied to a greater degree than usual that it is ‘fit for purpose'”.”

Liberty also says MI5 knew for three years of failures to maintain key safeguards — such as the timely destruction of material, and the protection of legally privileged material — before informing the IPCO.

Yet a key government sales pitch for passing the legislation was the claim of a ‘world class’ double-lock authorization and oversight regime to ensure the claimed safeguards on intelligence agencies powers to intercept and retain data.

So the latest revelations stemming from Liberty’s legal challenge represent a major embarrassment for the government.

“It is of course paramount that UK intelligence agencies demonstrate full compliance with the law,” the home secretary wrote in the statement last month, before adding his own political spin: “In that context, the interchange between the Commissioner and MI5 on this issue demonstrates that the world leading system of oversight established by the Act is working as it should.”

Liberty comes to the opposite conclusion on that point — emphasizing that warrants for bulk surveillance were issued by senior judges “on the understanding that MI5’s data handling obligations under the IPA were being met — when they were not”.

“The Commissioner has pointed out that warrants would not have been issued if breaches were known,” it goes on. “The Commissioner states that “it is impossible to sensibly reconcile the explanation of the handling of arrangements the Judicial Commissioners [senior judges] were given in briefings…with what MI5 knew over a protracted period of time was happening.”

So, basically, it’s saying that MI5 — having at best misled judges, whose sole job it is to oversee its legal access to data, about its systematic failures to lawfully handle data — has rather made a sham of the entire ‘world class’ oversight regime.

Liberty also flags what it calls “a remarkable admission to the Commissioner” — made by MI5’s deputy director general — who it says acknowledges that personal data collected by MI5 is being stored in “ungoverned spaces”. It adds that the MI5 legal team claims there is “a high likelihood [of material] being discovered when it should have been deleted, in a disclosure exercise leading to substantial legal or oversight failure”.

“Ungoverned spaces” is not a phrase that made it into Javid’s statement last month on MI5’s “compliance risks”.

But the home secretary did acknowledge: “A report of the Investigatory Powers Commissioner’s Office suggests that MI5 may not have had sufficient assurance of compliance with these safeguards within one of its technology environments.”

Javid also said he had set up “an independent review to consider and report back to me on what lessons can be learned for the future”. Though it’s unclear whether that report will be made public. 

We reached out to the Home Office for comment on the latest revelations from Liberty’s litigation. But a spokesman just pointed us to Javid’s prior statement. 

In a statement, Liberty’s lawyer, Megan Goulding, said: “These shocking revelations expose how MI5 has been illegally mishandling our data for years, storing it when they have no legal basis to do so. This could include our most deeply sensitive information – our calls and messages, our location data, our web browsing history.

“It is unacceptable that the public is only learning now about these serious breaches after the Government has been forced into revealing them in the course of Liberty’s legal challenge. In addition to showing a flagrant disregard for our rights, MI5 has attempted to hide its mistakes by providing misinformation to the Investigatory Powers Commissioner, who oversees the Government’s surveillance regime.

“And, despite a light being shone on this deplorable violation of our rights, the Government is still trying to keep us in the dark over further examples of MI5 seriously breaching the law.”

Read More



Leave A Comment

More News

TechCrunch » Social

Dropbox relaunches as an enterprise collaboration workspace 2019-06-11 13:19:37Dropbox is evolving from a file storage system to an enterprise software portal and collaboration workspace. Today the company launches a new version

Animal Crossing for Switch gets delayed 2019-06-11 12:46:28Fans had few expectations rolling into Nintendo’s E3 Direct that were more pronounced than hopes for more details on Animal Crossing for Switch.

Mobile games now account for 33% of installs, 2019-06-11 12:25:12Mobile gaming continues to hold its own, accounting for 10% of the time users spend in apps — a percentage that has remained steady over the yea

Here’s Mary Meeker’s 2019 internet trends report 2019-06-11 12:11:37Mary Meeker presents tech's favorite slide deck.

Verified Expert Growth Marketing Agency: Growth Pilots 2019-06-11 12:05:27Growth Pilots is one of the more exclusive performance marketing agencies in San Francisco, but they know how to help high-growth startups excel at pa

As Alzheimer’s costs soar, startups like Neurotrack raise 2019-06-11 12:00:36As studies show that early diagnosis and preventative therapies can help prevent the onset of Alzheimer’s, startups that are working to diagnose

72 hours left on early-bird savings for TC 2019-06-11 12:00:19We’re totally stoked to see all of you at TC Sessions: Mobility 2019 on July 10 in San Jose, Calif. That’s slightly less than a month away

Facebook’s new Study app pays adults for data 2019-06-11 11:59:28Facebook shut down its Research and Onavo programs after TechCrunch exposed how the company paid teenagers for root access to their phones to gain mar

Over 1,400 self-driving vehicles are now in testing 2019-06-11 11:54:22In a talk at the Uber Elevate Summit in Washington, D.C., today, U.S. Department of Transportation Secretary Elaine Chao shared a total overall figure

Mozilla gives Firefox a new logo as it 2019-06-11 11:47:55Mozilla’s Firefox is getting a new logo that is meant to reflect that the brand now stands for more than a browser. With products like its passw

Liberty’s challenge to UK state surveillance powers reveals 2019-06-11 11:43:46A legal challenge to the UK’s controversial mass surveillance regime has revealed shocking failures by the main state intelligence agency, which

Some sage security advice after Radiohead’s unreleased music 2019-06-11 11:42:38Bad news: Radiohead was hacked. Last week, a hacker stole the band’s lead singer Thom Yorke’s private minidisk archive from the band&rsquo

Mashable

All the data self-driving cars take in from New! 2019-06-18 13:00:00Self-driving cars are almost too observant, taking in information from light-emitting LiDAR sensors, radar equipment, microphones, and cameras. But al

Why do some people Capitalize Letters when they're New! 2019-06-18 12:18:07In the era of text messaging, tweeting, and digital communication, capitalization can be a Real Bitch. From a young age, we're trained to capitalize

The Anova Bluetooth sous vide cooker is $20 New! 2019-06-18 12:05:02TL;DR: This precise sous vide cooker from Anova Culinary is your best bet at achieving a perfect steak — pick one up on Amazon for just $78.78 (

Apple TV is getting picture-in-picture video playback New! 2019-06-18 11:56:30Apple is never keen to talk about forthcoming new features until they are ready to launch, but sometimes beta releases reveal stuff early. That's exa

So many health and wellness apps haven't done New! 2019-06-18 11:32:01With the explosion in health and wellness apps peddling self-improvement, your smartphone could one day hold the keys to helping you manage your lungs

Here's why the future of mobility is sucking New! 2019-06-18 11:30:02Based on how much we rely on shared transport services (Lime, Mobike, Uber Jump) today, it's safe to assume the next steps will involve driverless ve

Man straps GoPro to a turtle and gets New! 2019-06-18 11:26:01 Looks like Crush the turtle's totally gnarly cousin is shooting some sick pond footage.  But the credit truly goes to The Fish Whisperer, a Y

The 2-in-1 Acer Spin 5 has Alexa built New! 2019-06-18 11:16:57TL;DR: The 2-in-1 Acer Spin 5 is a serious Dell XPS competitor and it's only $799.99 at Amazon right now, saving you $200. You would think that wanti

Beats EP headphones are on sale for under New! 2019-06-18 11:07:13TL;DR: These durable Beats on-ear headphones usually cost $129.99, but you can grab a pair on sale at Walmart for just $73.99 — a $56 savings. B

Scientists just filmed a deep sea creature spew New! 2019-06-18 11:01:22At some 4,700 feet beneath the sea, marine scientists filmed a shrimp spew glowing matter, or bioluminescence, from its mouth.  This natural even

Inventor hacks up a perfectly good Tesla Model New! 2019-06-18 11:00:00Simone Giertz, the queen of shitty robots, modified her Tesla into a not-at-all-shitty pickup truck that she has dubbed "Truckla." The YouTuber and

The iPad Pro is on sale at Amazon New! 2019-06-18 10:50:22TL;DR: The all-powerful iPad Pro is the latest and greatest tablet from Apple — save $100 on Amazon and score one for just $699. When you think

The Next Web

This is how rich you’d be if you New! 2019-06-18 11:48:05People don’t usually regret their first bit of exciting hardware. On the contrary, the majority of folks have strong nostalgic feelings about th

Crypto Twitter responds to the reality of Facebook’s New! 2019-06-18 11:25:41Following months of speculation, Facebook finally confirmed the release of Libra next year. The tech giant also unveiled details about Calibra, its co

How to avoid spilling coffee on your expensive New! 2019-06-18 10:43:23DON’T DRINK COFFEE NEAR YOUR EXPENSIVE LAPTOP. For more gear, gadget, and hardware news and reviews, follow Plugged on Twitter and Flipboard.

EU lawmakers need to look beyond the ‘top New! 2019-06-18 10:00:19Brussels policy makers could be forgiven for wanting to move quickly to regulate ‘the internet.’ Assailed by an avalanche of public opinio

This $29 bundle lays the groundwork for any New! 2019-06-18 09:00:00Over eight courses featuring more than 20 hours of instruction, you’ll start gathering insight on the focal points of a winning business plan.

CHEAP: $270 off Harman Kardon’s Onyx 4 speaker New! 2019-06-18 08:52:42We’ve written quite a few times about cute and compact Bluetooth speakers. But today, we’re bringing a mega deal for a top-shelf speaker.&

How YouTube became the app parents love to New! 2019-06-18 08:48:33Over the last several months, YouTube has reeled from a wave of criticism. It has been accused of radicalizing young voters, ignoring harassment of LG

How 3D spintronics will take hard drive performance New! 2019-06-18 08:37:08Spintronics might not be the sort of word that comes up in everyday discussions, but it has been revolutionising computer technology for years. It&rsq

How to get started with mind mapping apps New! 2019-06-18 08:34:26Welcome to TNW Basics, a collection of tips, guides, and advice on how to easily get the most out of your gadgets, apps, and other stuff. List ma

An open letter to my Macbook Pro, on New! 2019-06-18 08:32:52My dearest MacBook Pro, I’m sorry. I’m so, so sorry. It wasn’t meant to be like this. We’ve spent five beautiful years togethe

‘Crypto Twitter’ anxiously awaits white paper for Facebook’s 2019-06-17 12:13:52Tomorrow, Facebook is expected to release full details of its new “cryptocurrency” project Libra — as always, Twitter

AIs should be legally liable for their mistakes 2019-06-17 11:03:54Assigning blame can often be a complex task. A person’s actions, intentions, and state of mind all come into consideration when meting out judge

Entrepreneur

Avoid Negativity by Embracing This Hidden Part of New! 2019-06-18 13:30:00Jack Canfield says that meeting your goals can be as easy as appealing to the person inside you.

Why Apple Evangelist Oleksandr Kosovan Is Competing With New! 2019-06-18 13:00:00He spent over a month's salary on his first Apple keyboard and lived in a dorm room while starting his business. This is his story.

The Ugly Truth About 'Vanity Metrics': 3 Keys New! 2019-06-18 12:30:00Data is hardly in short supply, which is why it's so important to understand what to measure and how it relates to your business.

Don't Get Duped by This Sneaky Google Calendar New! 2019-06-18 12:04:17Despite what that Google Calendar invite says, you probably didn't win a bunch of money.

Chick-fil-A Is Now the 3rd-Largest Restaurant Chain in New! 2019-06-18 11:59:50Chick-fil-A moved up from the No. 7 spot on last year's Top 200 ranking, passing Wendy's, Burger King, Taco Bell and Subway.

4 Tech Trends Shaping the Future of Media New! 2019-06-18 11:30:00We've all heard about AR, VR and blockchain, but what exactly are entertainment and media businesses doing with these technologies?

Want to Become a Billionaire? Invest in Your New! 2019-06-18 10:30:00Many investors haven't kept up with inflation over the last 20 years. Have you?

This Entrepreneur Stars in a Hit Network Series, New! 2019-06-18 10:00:00You've seen June Diane Raphael in "Grace and Frankie," but did you know she founded the first workspace to offer child care?

3 Things That Make Angel Investors Want to New! 2019-06-18 09:10:00Here are the key ingredients for a pitch that wins over angel investors.

Facebook's Cryptocurrency: Everything We Know So Far New! 2019-06-18 09:03:16Facebook's big blockchain play will reportedly create a crypto-based payments ecosystem across Facebook, Messenger, Instagram, WhatsApp and beyond.

How One Man Went From Maintaining Sports Fields New! 2019-06-18 08:30:00The athletic director for the University of Texas breaks down his journey to the top.

4 Things Leaders Misunderstand About Performance Reviews New! 2019-06-18 08:00:00Workers crave feedback, but feedback loops often go wrong.

E-Commerce Times

For Brands the Future Is Facebook 2019-06-07 11:48:39Mark Zuckerberg recently said that the future of Facebook is private. Interestingly, connecting the dots between all the announcements made at Faceboo

When Retail Customers Take It on the Chin, 2019-06-06 13:42:14I am a reluctant Costco shopper. My wife is one of the many who really love the chain. Me... not so much. Seriously -- someone should knock Costco's

7 Critical Skills for Running an E-Commerce Business 2019-06-05 18:47:34There are many benefits to running an e-commerce business, whether you operate purely online or not. Online transactions allow you to expand your reac

New Antitrust Probe Tightens Screws on Big Tech 2019-06-05 13:24:14The U.S. House of Representatives Antitrust Subcommittee has opened an investigation into competition in digital markets, increasing the pressure on b

Trailhead, Salesforce's Not-So-Secret Weapon 2019-06-04 14:50:29Salesforce has used its Trailhead learning system to teach developers how to program on its Lightning platform for more than five years. The company l

Stripe Offers SMBs Chargeback Fraud Relief 2019-06-04 06:21:10Payment processing company Stripe has launched Chargeback Protection, a machine learning-based system to limit the impact of fraudulent credit card tr

The Importance of Strong Domain Security to Brand 2019-06-03 15:14:11Building and sustaining a brand has gotten more challenging. The global marketplace, empowered by the Internet, has delivered a raft of opportunities

The Cannabis Rush: Where There's Smoke, There's E-Commerce 2019-05-31 08:00:00The budding online cannabis industry has a long way to go before it delivers bumper crops. The market for both recreational and medicinal cannabis has

Trailblazing a Path for Blockchain 2019-05-30 14:24:26Many of us think of blockchain as the technology that prevents counterfeiting digital currencies like bitcoin. However, the so-called cryptocurrencies

Amazon to Edge Out Small Wholesalers 2019-05-30 06:16:16Amazon has been reworking relationships with several of its long-time wholesale suppliers in a bid to cut costs, according to a report. The plan is to

Getting Chatty With Chatbots 2019-05-28 15:04:49Chatbots are an important part of the e-commerce shopping experience. They answer questions, provide information, and help customers along in their bu

Leveraging the Tools That Fuel E-Commerce Growth 2019-05-25 08:00:00E-commerce technologies have been innovating fast. It's no surprise, considering e-commerce in North America grew by 15 percent in 2018, to reach mor

Social News Daily

Topless Lady Shuts Down Anti-Abortion Protest Out Front 2019-06-07 17:34:45A topless woman’s scheme to take on an anti-abortion protest in front of a high school had her baring her boobies in front of both students and

It’s On – KFC Has Began Selling Chicken 2019-06-06 17:02:20The fries are essentially like fried chicken pieces, minus the actual flesh within – leaving the signature-spiced covering that KFC is famed for

Ex-Con Sticks Up Two Banks Armed With An 2019-06-06 11:39:50An ex-con’s caught after stealing tens of thousands of currency from several banks by vowing to ‘blow up’ a painted avocado. A 47-ye

Colossal Penis Mowed Into Field For Trump To 2019-06-05 17:07:07There are lots of ways you can make Pres. Trump feel welcome: you can offer him coffee, or mow a penis into a field for him to view as his plane lands

How Companies Can Use Social Media to Their 2019-06-04 09:13:25Social media has made advertising much easier for companies looking to put their products out in full view of the public. You can reach a wide audienc

Why Climbers Continue To Die On Mount Everest 2019-06-03 19:14:52Bodies all over, why? Well, Mount Everest climbers have different causes of death, however here are some of the most common. Mount Everest is said to

2019’s Most Brutal Trump Memes So Far 2019-06-01 10:30:06The year isn’t even halfway over, yet Donald Trump has managed to make a fool of himself and our country countless times. From inviting the nati

9 Epic Photos From Abortion Ban Protests Around 2019-06-01 09:00:23Republicans have always said that when they gained control in Congress, they would work to overturn Roe v. Wade and here they are, cashing in on that

‘Rat Bar’ Pop-Up Where You Can Pay To 2019-05-31 18:10:50The San Francisco Dungeon renowned for its interactive history tours, featuring enthralling special effects and live actors, is opening its Rat Bar. S

This College Is Actually Paying People To NOT 2019-05-31 17:06:38A college wants to compensate incoming in-state students to delay their inaugural date and not attend the campus for up to a year. Virginia Tech budge

Woman Asks For $100,000 Via GoFundMe Page Because… 2019-05-31 12:14:44If only all our non-urgent monetary problems in the world could be fixed with the invisible patrons of GoFundMe. Apparently, that’s a popular id

Need To Lose Weight? Try Crying At Night, 2019-05-31 11:09:48Weight loss tips and studies are a dime-a-dozen these days and some of them are quite costly even and discouraging. Of course, there are some affordab


Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.